Six O’Clock Vintage

Seek those images that constitute the wild, the lion and the virgin, the harlot and the child. Find in middle air an eagle on the wing, recognize the five that make the Muses sing. | W.B Yeats, Those Images

Kinkadian Pornography

Thomas Kinkade’s art is Pornographic.”

The potentially hyperbolic statement above comes straight from the lips of my Aesthetics Professor, who also happens to be the head of the Art Department. Of course, the idea is that uninspired, unimaginative, and consumer-driven imagery is not art and is actually degrading to look at when it is deceptively purveyed as having aesthetic value.

There is another adjective for this sort of non-aesthetic rubbish: kitsch.

Calinescu writes in regard to kitsch that it “dismisses the claims or pretensions of quality of anything that tries to be ‘artistic’ without genuinely being so.” He describes it as “aesthetic deception and self-deception,” and damns it for always implying “aesthetic inadequacy.”

“We have only to think of the horrendous old ‘curiosities’ that are on sale in the increasingly numerous nostalgia shops–rotten boots, broken cart wheels, porcelain night-pots, unwieldy rusty bathtubs of two or three generations ago, and inumerable other shabby junky ‘antiques,’ which many people enjoy as poetic relics from the better world of our grandfathers.”

Kundera tells us “the brotherhood of man on earth will be possible only on a base of kitsch.”

To me the idea of kitsch as base seems to have plurality of meaning, for true universal brotherhood must exist at the basest of levels, at the lowest common denominator; and your Pottery Barn prints may lead straight to an uninspired aesthetic hell.

Just be careful next time you choose your wall paper, and consider purging your house of souvenirs…

These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • co.mments
  • Technorati

Activity

6 total comments, leave your comment or trackback.
  1. Anonymous
    Apr 18th 2005

    Commercial artists may be uninspired “sell-outs”, but they are also the only artists who make any money. Art students like to believe that people will actually buy their abstract collages and cast-iron sculptures. Unfortunately, they are in for quite a rude awakening when they enter the real world.

    If you are drawing/painting for the sake of your own artistic expression that’s wonderful, and don’t look to Thomas Kinkade for your inspiration.

    On the other hand, if you actually want to make a living with an artistic craft he’s a fine example seeing as he makes way more money than any of us artistically-inclined bloggers.

    The trick is finding a balance between your own creative expression and satisfaction and producing something that will make it past the commitee.

  2. briana
    Apr 18th 2005

    so i see you’ve tossed Kundera into your well of literary influences–have you read anything yet?

  3. Briana: The only Kundera I’ve read has been a selection from one of his novels (the selection had to do with the Soviet May Day Celebrations). I bet you’ve probably been exposed to a lot of his writing with your poli-sci background. Do you especially recommend any of his works?

  4. briana
    Apr 19th 2005

    Actually I didn’t hear of him at all in college. I picked up “The Unbearable Lightness of Being” in Manchester Airport at Christmas. I picked it off the shelf because of the picture on the front. (I’m a very book-by-it’s-cover sort of person). If you read the Carlos Fuentes selection in Aesthetics, he references this one. The quote above is from it, too. You’d like it. Read it with a responsible mind, though.

    I just finished “Life is Elsewhere.” It’s a lot less difficult than the first, but you’d definitely like it.

    I don’t know how steeped you are in the history of Czechoslovakia, especially during the 1940’s to 1970’s, but it would add depth to your experience of his works to read up on it a little. His ideas reach farther than his country and his time, but you gotta know the context, but you know that…

    I’m excited to read more–I just ordered another stack–I’ll let you know what’s essential. But so far, in my opinion, those two certainly are.

  5. I jsut googled “kinkade and kitsch” and foun a funny site I thought I’d pass along:

    Thomas Kinkade: Painter of Crap

  6. >>Kundera tells us “the brotherhood of man on earth will be possible only on a base of kitsch.”< <

    Taken at face value, that is one of the more horrifying quotations I’ve heard in awhile. *shudder*

    A lot of Christian “bookstores” could be better described as “kitschstores,” so some Christians should be well on the way to that universal ideal…